The two promises every CIO has to keep
Every CIO I've worked with has been holding two promises at once. The first is to the board: leave it with me, I'll deliver this. The second is to everyone else in the business: this change is going to make your working life better.
For a long time the first promise was the bigger one. The board set the direction and the CIO went and made it happen. That has shifted. In this episode of The Next Thing Now, Darren Kerwick described the modern CIO as something closer to a business architect. The CIO, CTO and chief digital officer roles have folded into one. The board is as likely to ask "how do we get there?" as it is to say "go and do this". The CIO helps set the direction of travel and then delivers it.
That's a much bigger job, and trust is what holds it together.
Both promises are under pressure
Both promises are harder to keep right now than at any point I can remember.
The board has been told AI will transform everything. So has the workforce. The vendors and the media have promised quite a lot of magic, and the CIO sits in the middle of it. The board wants magic delivered. The teams expect magic at their level too. And many of those same people are legitimately worried that the magic means their role disappears.
We've seen this kind of gold rush before. When we started Dootrix, everyone wanted a mobile app. Nobody was quite sure why. The last year of AI has rhymed with that. Buy everyone a licence. Roll out Copilot. Wait and see. If you can't say what the licence is for, you're adding cost and distraction. People mess around, get confused, and the business benefit never arrives.
Be specific
Darren's answer is to pick three to five measurable mandates and build everything around them. Reduce customer processing times by 20%. Cut the time it takes to respond to a customer. Something you can point at and measure.
At a luxury resort group Darren worked with, putting together a tailored offer for a prospective guest used to take the sales team three weeks. By then, plenty of guests had booked somewhere else. With process automation, CRM and AI working together, that came down to three minutes.
The sales team stayed the same size. They stopped building quotes and started having proper conversations with guests about what they wanted from their stay. The likelihood of a guest booking again rose from 33% to 87%.
That's the version of AI efficiency that builds trust. The drudgery goes. People get to do the work they're good at. The customer feels understood, and the business can see the number move.
The revolving door
Fifteen years ago it was normal to walk into an organisation and meet a CIO who'd been there a decade. They knew the place inside out. Now the transient CIO is far more common: in for 18 months to deliver an ERP rollout, then gone. Some are fractional. Some sit on a private equity firm's bench and get moved from business to business. Darren had heard a figure recently that puts average CIO tenure at around 18 months, and falling.
There's a place for specialists. Darren has been one, brought in to roll out SAP S/4HANA for a chemical manufacturer. He's also been the portfolio CIO holding the long-term vision above them. The trouble starts when nobody holds that vision. Every new arrival decides the last roadmap was wrong and writes a new one, and the business spins in circles every 18 months.
Over the summer I was in an organisation that had just hired its third CIO in five years. The new CIO had a clear vision for AI. The cynicism in the building was palpable. People had watched two CIOs arrive, make promises and leave before the consequences landed. They had no reason to believe the third would be any different.
That's what the revolving door costs. Each exit spends a little more of the trust the next person needs.
Experience matters more now
AI makes this trap easier to fall into. Boards want someone shiny. Nobody has ten years of AI transformation on their CV, because the technology has only been around for a few minutes. And AI transformation is a whole-business transformation. It touches every process, every role and every customer relationship.
What that calls for is someone who has been through a full transformation before, ideally several times. Someone who lived through Y2K, GDPR and the mobile rush, and can smell where the problems are. Those leaders run a risk of their own: ask the prudent questions and you can get written off as a stick in the mud. Those prudent questions are exactly what stop a business from becoming a busy fool.
Trust is built in person
Almost every signal that used to say "we care about you" is now free. A polished deck, a personalised email, a personalised video, even a handwritten note can all be produced at the press of a button. When anything can be generated, very little of it signals effort.
Showing up still does. Walking the floor. Sitting with a team. Making a cup of tea with someone and finding out what makes them tick. In a world of AI and remote working, giving someone your time in person might be the only high-value signal left.
Where a CIO starts on Monday
A CIO walking in at the start of this journey can keep it simple. Pick three to five things you can deliver. Build working groups around them with people from every level of the business, so they shape the outcome and own the change alongside you. Get quick wins early, because quick wins buy you the time to do the long-term work. And be on the floor, genuinely interested in the people whose working lives you're changing.
Both promises can still be kept. It takes specific goals, visible progress and a leader who stays long enough to see it through. Trust is vital to all of it, and it has to be earned one delivery at a time.